EcologyIntermediateExperiment simulation~15 min

Biodiversity and Ecosystem Stability

Does it matter how many species live in an ecosystem? Run an experiment that ecologists have carried out for real: grow three meadows with different numbers of plant species, hit them with the same drought, heatwave or disease, and compare how well each one copes and recovers.

Calm
t = 0.0 s

Each plot is a square of meadow seen from above; each coloured dot is a plant, coloured by species. All three plots contain ryegrass.

16

Changing this starts a new experiment.

Conditions
—
Plot A (1 species)
—
Plot B (4 species)
—
Plot C
—

Plant growth in each plot

Total plant growth in each plot as a percentage of the maximum, with disturbances marked.

    How to use this simulator

    1. Let the three plots grow. Note that the mixed plots end up slightly more productive than the monoculture.
    2. Press Drought, Heatwave or Ryegrass disease. All three plots are hit at the same time.
    3. Compare how far each plot’s growth falls (resistance) and how quickly it recovers (resilience) in the readouts and graph.
    4. Watch which species survive and spread in the diverse plots while others suffer.
    5. Change the number of species in plot C and repeat. Is there a point where adding more species makes little difference?

    What is biodiversity?

    Biodiversity is the variety of life on Earth. It is usually described at three levels:genetic diversity (differences between individuals of the same species), species diversity (how many different species there are and how evenly they are spread), and ecosystem diversity (the range of habitats, from coral reefs to grasslands). Scientists have described about 2 million species, but there may be 8 million or more.

    Diversity and stability

    Ecosystems are constantly disturbed by droughts, storms, pests and diseases. In a diverse community, species react differently: when a drought kills a shallow-rooted grass, a deep-rooted plant or a drought-tolerant clover may survive and expand into the space. Total plant growth stays more stable even though individual species rise and fall. This is known as the insurance hypothesis: the more species there are, the more likely it is that some will cope with whatever happens.

    The experiment behind the model

    At Cedar Creek in Minnesota, ecologist David Tilman and colleagues planted 168 grassland plots with between 1 and 16 species and measured them for decades. Plots with more species produced more plant growth and varied much less from year to year. During severe droughts, diverse plots lost far less productivity and recovered faster. Similar results have since been found in many experiments around the world.

    Why biodiversity matters to people

    • Food security: crop diversity and wild relatives protect against pests and diseases. The Irish potato famine of the 1840s struck a country depending on very few potato varieties.
    • Pollination: about three quarters of food crops benefit from animal pollinators.
    • Clean water and air, fertile soils and flood control all depend on healthy ecosystems.
    • Medicines: many drugs, from aspirin to cancer treatments, come from wild organisms.

    Keystone species

    Some species matter far more than their numbers suggest. Sea otters eat sea urchins; without otters, urchins strip kelp forests bare. Beavers build dams that create wetlands used by hundreds of other species. Losing akeystone species can cause an entire ecosystem to change.

    Threats to biodiversity

    The main causes of biodiversity loss today are habitat loss from farming and building,overexploitation through overfishing and hunting, climate change,pollution and invasive species. Wildlife populations monitored worldwide have fallen by around two thirds on average since 1970, and about a million species are estimated to be at risk of extinction.

    Protecting biodiversity

    Protected areas, habitat restoration, wildlife corridors that link habitats, sustainable farming and fishing, controlling invasive species, and seed banks all help. Even small actions, such as leaving wildflower patches for pollinators, add up.

    Interesting facts

    • Scientists have named roughly 2 million species, but estimates of the total number on Earth run to several million more, most of them insects and other small organisms.
    • Tropical rainforests cover only a small fraction of Earth’s land yet are thought to hold around half of all land species.
    • The Philippines is one of the world’s biodiversity hotspots, with many species found nowhere else, such as the Philippine eagle and the tarsier.

    Key terms

    Monoculture
    Growing a single species over a large area.
    Resistance / resilience
    How little an ecosystem changes during a disturbance / how quickly it recovers afterwards.
    Ecosystem services
    The benefits people get from nature, such as food, clean water and pollination.

    Common misconceptions

    • “Biodiversity just means lots of animals.” It includes plants, fungi, microbes, genes and habitats.
    • “Losing one species doesn’t matter.” Each loss removes a role and a backup in the ecosystem; keystone losses can be dramatic.
    • “Monocultures are always more productive.” Diverse systems often match or exceed them, and are far more stable.

    Key takeaways

    • Biodiversity is the variety of genes, species and ecosystems.
    • Diverse ecosystems resist disturbances better and recover faster.
    • Different species use resources in different ways, often making diverse systems more productive.
    • Habitat loss is the leading cause of biodiversity decline.

    Model note: species traits are invented for the demonstration and the plots are simplified. The pattern, more stability with more species, matches long-term field experiments.

    Knowledge check

    Biodiversity and Ecosystem Stability: test your understanding

    Answer each question to get instant feedback and an explanation. Use the simulator to check your thinking.

    8 questions3 basic3 intermediate2 advanced

    0 of 8 answered

    1. Q1BasicWhat does biodiversity mean?
      Show answer

      Answer: B. The variety of life: genes, species and ecosystems

      Biodiversity includes genetic diversity within species, the variety of species, and the variety of ecosystems.

    2. Q2BasicIn the simulator, why does the monoculture (plot A) collapse during the ryegrass disease, while plot C barely changes?
      Show answer

      Answer: B. In plot C, other species are not affected by the disease and quickly fill the space

      When one species is hit, others take over its role. Relying on a single species puts everything at risk, as in the Irish potato famine.

    3. Q3IntermediateWhat is the “insurance hypothesis” of biodiversity?
      Show answer

      Answer: A. Diverse ecosystems are more likely to include species that can cope with any particular disturbance

      Different species respond differently to droughts, heat, pests and diseases, so a mix keeps the ecosystem working whatever happens.

    4. Q4IntermediateEcologists talk about resistance and resilience. What is resilience?
      Show answer

      Answer: B. How quickly an ecosystem recovers after a disturbance

      Resistance is how much it changes during the disturbance; resilience is how fast it bounces back. Compare the lowest points and recovery times in the graph.

    5. Q5AdvancedLong-term grassland experiments found that plots with more species tend to be more productive. Why?
      Show answer

      Answer: A. Species use space, light, water and nutrients in different ways, so together they use resources more fully

      This is complementarity: deep and shallow roots, early and late growth, and nitrogen-fixing legumes such as clover all add to total growth.

    6. Q6IntermediateWhat is a keystone species?
      Show answer

      Answer: B. A species with a much larger effect on its ecosystem than its numbers suggest

      Examples include sea otters, which eat sea urchins and protect kelp forests, and beavers, whose dams create wetlands.

    7. Q7BasicWhich is currently the biggest cause of biodiversity loss worldwide?
      Show answer

      Answer: B. Habitat loss and land-use change

      Clearing land for farming and building is the leading cause, followed by overexploitation, climate change, pollution and invasive species.

    8. Q8AdvancedIn the simulator, why does adding species beyond about four or five give smaller extra benefits during a drought?
      Show answer

      Answer: B. Once at least one drought-tolerant species is present, more species add less extra insurance for that particular threat

      But many different threats occur over time, so higher diversity keeps paying off across droughts, heat, pests and diseases.

    References and further reading

    1. Tilman, D., Reich, P. B., & Knops, J. M. H. (2006). Biodiversity and ecosystem stability in a decade-long grassland experiment. Nature, 441, 629–632. doi.org (opens in a new tab)
    2. Isbell, F., et al. (2015). Biodiversity increases the resistance of ecosystem productivity to climate extremes. Nature, 526, 574–577. doi.org (opens in a new tab)
    3. Yachi, S., & Loreau, M. (1999). Biodiversity and ecosystem productivity in a fluctuating environment: the insurance hypothesis. PNAS, 96(4), 1463–1468.
    4. IPBES (2019). Global Assessment Report on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services: Summary for Policymakers. ipbes.net (opens in a new tab)

    This simulator is a simplified educational model. Found an error? Let us know. See our educational disclaimer.